Apply directly by default. Bring in an agency recruiter for contract work, for senior or confidential searches, and for narrow specialties where a few firms hold most of the openings. The reason is money, not loyalty: when an agency places you, the employer pays a fee on top of your salary.
SHRM put the usual contingency fee at around 20 to 25% of a role's first-year cash compensation in 2016, so a $100,000 hire through an agency can cost the employer $20,000 to $25,000 before you start. Sometimes that fee buys a search the company could never run itself. Sometimes, between two close finalists, it quietly tips things the other way.
Who pays a recruiter, and how much?
Not you. The hiring company pays. The US Federal Trade Commission puts it plainly: legitimate placement firms and headhunters "typically don't charge prospective employees. Instead, they're paid by the company looking for qualified candidates" (FTC consumer alert, January 2023). In the UK it is the law rather than a norm. GOV.UK says recruitment agencies "cannot charge you a fee for finding or trying to find you work" (they can offer paid extras like CV writing, but can't make them a condition of finding you work).
What the employer pays depends on the kind of recruiter:
- In-house recruiters are employees of the company. If one messages you, that is a direct application with a person attached. No fee.
- Contingency agencies are paid only if their candidate is hired. SHRM (2016) gave "20 percent to 25 percent of the role's first-year cash compensation" as the usual range, counting salary, bonus and signing bonus.
- Retained search firms are paid to run the search, mostly for senior roles. The same 2016 SHRM piece put the standard fee at about 33% of salary, bonus and signing bonus.
- Staffing firms place contractors and temps. Instead of a one-off fee, they bill the client an hourly rate, pay you a lower hourly rate, and keep the difference.
Source: SHRM (July 2016); GOV.UK agency worker rights; FTC consumer alert (Jan 2023); checked Nov 2026
What the fee looks like in dollars
Percentages hide how large these sums are. Here is the same 20 to 25% contingency range applied to four salaries. It is plain arithmetic on SHRM's range, and real contracts vary: some firms charge less, some add guarantees or charge more for hard searches.
Fee paid by the employer, by first-year salary
| $60k salary | $12k to $15k |
| $80k salary | $16k to $20k |
| $100k salary | $20k to $25k |
| $140k salary | $28k to $35k |
Salary only. SHRM's range is applied to cash compensation, so a bonus or signing bonus raises the fee further.
Source: Arithmetic on SHRM's typical contingency range (2016)
The same arithmetic explains a common worry, that a recruiter will not push hard on your pay. If a recruiter on a 20% fee gets your offer raised from $100,000 to $105,000, their fee rises by $1,000. Closing the deal at all is worth $20,000 to them. So their incentive is real but small at the margin, and speed matters more to them than squeezing the last few thousand. That doesn't make them useless in a negotiation. They can carry an awkward message for you. Just don't assume your interests and theirs line up exactly.
Why a company might prefer a direct applicant
Put yourself in the hiring manager's seat with two similar finalists. One arrived through the careers page. The other comes with a $20,000 invoice. Nobody will say the fee decided it, and often it doesn't. The fee itself never helps the agency candidate. The recruiter can: if the manager has hired through that person before, the candidate arrives already screened by someone they trust.
There are other reasons too. A direct applicant chose the company rather than being pitched to it. There is no risk of a fee dispute over who introduced the candidate first. And when a company advertises a role on its own careers page, it is inviting applications that cost it nothing extra. That page is worth checking before you agree to be submitted anywhere. In our feed, about 28% of new postings in the 30 days to November 7, 2026 came straight from company hiring systems such as Workday and Greenhouse, which is a lot of employers asking for direct applications. Our page on applying on the company website or LinkedIn covers what happens after you click.
| Agency recruiter | Applying directly | |
|---|---|---|
| Works for | The employer, its client | You |
| Cost to you | Nothing, if legitimate | Nothing |
| Extra cost to the employer | Often 20 to 25% of first-year pay | None |
| Unadvertised roles | Yes, often its main value | Rarely |
| Who pitches you | The recruiter, by phone | Your resume and answers |
| Where your resume goes | Wherever they send it, unless you set rules | Only where you send it |
| Career changers | Rarely pitched | Fine |
| Best for | Contract, senior, niche roles | Most posted roles |
Fee range from SHRM (2016). "Unadvertised roles" means roles the employer gave only to the agency.
When a recruiter is worth it
We're a site built around applying directly, and we'd still use a recruiter in these cases:
- Contract and contract-to-hire work. Many large companies fill contractor roles only through approved staffing suppliers. In IT contracting, healthcare and light industrial work, the agency is often the only door. If the terms are new to you, our explainer on direct hire vs contract vs contract-to-hire sets them side by side.
- Senior and confidential searches. When a company is replacing an executive who hasn't left yet, the role is never posted. A retained firm runs it.
- Narrow specialties. If you are one of a few hundred people who do your job, the specialist recruiters in your field may know more openings than any job board.
- Moving to a new city or country. A local recruiter knows which employers sponsor, which pay well and which have a reputation.
- Inside knowledge. A recruiter who has placed people with a hiring manager before can tell you what that person screens for and why the last finalist was turned down. That is hard to get any other way.
- A better shot at the first screen. In Ashby's data on hiring at its customers from 2021 to 2024, 42% of agency candidates got an interview, against 3% of inbound applicants, the people who applied themselves through a careers page or a board. Agencies only put forward people they expect to fit, so part of that gap is selection, and Ashby doesn't say how many applications it covers. After the interview the gap mostly closes: 8% of interviewed agency candidates reached an offer, against 6% of inbound ones.
When a recruiter can cost you the job
The classic failure is the double submission. You apply on the careers page on Monday; an agency submits you to the same company on Wednesday without asking. Now the employer has a possible fee dispute over who introduced you, and the easiest way out is to pass on you. Avoid it with one rule, stated on the first call: nobody submits you anywhere without your OK, every time.
Recruiters can also work against you when you are a stretch candidate. They fill orders with close matches because that is what clients pay for, so a career changer rarely gets pitched. And your resume can travel further than you meant it to. LinkedIn's own help pages note that an Easy Apply to a job posted by a recruiting agency may be shared with that agency's other clients.
A recruiter contacted you about a job that's also posted. Now what?
This one comes up a lot, and the answer depends on who the recruiter works for. Check their LinkedIn profile or email signature first. If they work for the company, reply and go through them; that is applying directly. If they work for an agency, ask whether the company engaged them for this role and whether they are the only agency on it. If they are, the hiring manager may expect candidates through them, and going around them can look odd. If they are one of several agencies on a role that is also on the careers page, you can apply directly instead, but tell them you have, so nobody submits you twice.
If you go direct, a short note to the hiring manager after applying does part of the pitching a recruiter would have done. Our guide on asking for a referral covers the stronger version of that.
Hi [First name], The [job title] role sounds interesting, and I'm happy to talk. Two things before you share my details anywhere: 1. Please check with me before you submit me to a company, every time. 2. I've already applied directly to [Company A] and [Company B], so please leave those two out. Could you also tell me who the client is, if you're the only agency on it, and the pay range? I'm free [two time slots]. [Your name]
Send it before the first call. Keep your own list of where you have applied and who submitted you where.
Questions to ask before a recruiter submits you
- Who is the client, and have you placed people with this hiring manager before?
- Are you the only agency on this role, or one of several?
- Is the pay range the client's figure or your estimate?
- Is it permanent, contract or contract-to-hire, and whose payroll would I be on?
- Can I see the exact resume you will send?
- Will you check the company does not already have my application?
Where DirectRoles fits
We are not a recruiter. We don't submit you anywhere and nobody pays us when you are hired. We build a job feed and you apply yourself. Our main job sources are queried with staffing-agency postings switched off, and any agency postings that still come through are listed below employer postings. Where the employer posts on its own careers page, we link you there so your application goes straight in. Not every posting comes from a company system, though: about 58% of our feed in the 30 days to November 7, 2026 reached us through job boards and aggregator feeds. Our direct employer jobs page shows the current split.
Questions people ask
Does using a recruiter lower my salary?
Not for a permanent job: the agency fee is paid by the employer on top of your salary, not taken out of it. It can affect the offer indirectly if the employer has a fixed total budget for the hire. For contract work through a staffing firm, the firm's margin sits between what the client pays and what you are paid.
Can I apply directly after a recruiter has contacted me?
Yes, if the recruiter has not submitted you yet. Tell them you are applying yourself so they do not submit you as well. If they already have, stay with them for that role; a second, direct application only creates a dispute about who introduced you.
Do companies prefer candidates who apply directly?
Between two equally strong candidates, often, because there is no fee. But if a company has hired a retained search firm for a senior role, it expects candidates to come through that firm, and a cold application may simply be passed to the firm.
Should I pay a recruiter or career agent to find me a job?
No. The FTC says honest placement firms do not typically charge candidates, and UK agencies cannot charge you for finding you work. Paying a career coach for advice is a different, legitimate service, but anyone who charges you for placement or "guaranteed interviews" should be treated as a red flag.
What is the difference between an in-house recruiter and an agency recruiter?
An in-house recruiter is employed by the company that is hiring and costs it no fee per hire. An agency recruiter works for an outside firm that is paid when it fills the role. A message from an in-house recruiter is the company itself reaching out.
Is a headhunter the same as a recruiter?
People use the words loosely. "Headhunter" usually means a recruiter who approaches people who are not job hunting, often for senior roles and often on a retained search. In the UK you will also hear "recruitment consultant" for agency recruiters.
